The Originator for over 25 years in Pay Per Head

Toronto Blue Jays vs. New York Yankees 9/19/23 MLB Odds, Tips and Analysis

Toronto Blue Jays (83-67) vs. New York Yankees (76-74)

As the MLB season inches closer to its conclusion, a high-stakes match-up between the Toronto Blue Jays and the New York Yankees is set to captivate baseball fans this Tuesday evening. With the Blue Jays currently at 83-67 and the Yankees at 76-74, this game could be a turning point for both teams’ postseason aspirations. For those looking for free baseball picks, you’re in for a treat as this matchup promises not only competitive play but also intriguing betting odds.

Toronto comes into this game holding a strong 83-67 record, impressing particularly with their batting lineup. Their team stats feature a .257 batting average, a .329 on-base percentage, and a solid slugging percentage of .415. Their 172 home runs and 679 runs also speak to the offensive capability of this team. While the Blue Jays have struggled against the Yankees recently, with a 3-6 straight-up record in their last 9 meetings, they have performed admirably against other teams in the American League East Division with a 7-2 straight-up record.

The New York Yankees enter this matchup with an even lower record: 76-74 – placing them in more dire need of victory than Toronto. Although their batting average of .226 and on-base percentage of .304 may not compare favourably, they have scored more homers at 208 while boasting a competitive slugging percentage of .397; their pitching staff has maintained an ERA of 3.97. The Yankees have proven they can perform against Toronto over time, which may give them an advantage in this crucial matchup.


Toronto Blue Jays vs. New York Yankees Game Info

When:Tuesday, September 19, 2023, at 7:05 PM ET
Where:Yankee Stadium


Yusei Kikuchi (9-6 W-L, 3.81 ERA) vs. Clarke Schmidt (9-8 W-L, 4.56 ERA)

Toronto will send Yusei Kikuchi out on the mound, which currently boasts a 9-6 win-loss record and 3.81 ERA over 153.2 innings pitched. Kikuchi has allowed 147 hits while striking out 163 batters and walking 45 over that span; his strengths include an influential ERA and ability to limit walks; however, his 26 homerun total could pose problems against New York’s prolific homer hitters.

Clarke Schmidt will take the mound for the Yankees on Tuesday. Schmidt currently owns a 9-8 record and 4.56 ERA over 146 innings pitched, yielding 154 hits while striking out 142 and walking 41. His ability to limit walks to an acceptable level while maintaining an effective strikeout ratio and limited homer runs allowed (21) may prove crucial against Toronto’s powerful bats.


MLB Odds/Point Spread: Toronto Blue Jays -111, Total Odds: 8.5

The betting odds slightly favor Toronto with a moneyline of -111. The point spread for the Blue Jays is -1.5 with a +150 payoff, whereas the Yankees are at +1.5 with a -170 payoff. The total is set at 8.5, with the over at -115 and the under at -105.


Toronto Blue Jays Betting Trends

The Blue Jays have had a mixed bag of outcomes recently. They are 3-6 in their last 9 games against the Yankees but 7-2 in their last 9 against the American League East Division. The total has gone OVER in 5 of their last 6 road games but has stayed UNDER in their last 6 road games against the Yankees.


New York Yankees Betting Trends

The Yankees are in good form with a 6-2 straight-up record in their last 8 games. Interestingly, the total has gone UNDER in 10 of their last 13 games against Toronto but has gone OVER in 9 of their last 13 home games. Their performance against the American League has been impressive with an 8-2 straight-up record in their last 10 games.


Toronto Blue Jays vs. New York Yankees 9/19/23 Betting Picks

This game could go either way, but the edge seems to slightly favor the Blue Jays, particularly in their recent form against other American League East teams and their overall stronger stats. However, the Yankees cannot be ruled out, especially given their recent success against Toronto.

If you’re looking to place a bet, consider the Blue Jays on the moneyline at -111. For those interested in prop bets or over/under, the total set at 8.5 looks enticing for an over bet, especially considering Toronto’s recent road game trends. You can find these odds at the best online casinos.

Free Pick and Prediction: Toronto Blue Jays 6, New York Yankees 4

Start your online gaming site with IDSCA

Try us for a week for free, and explore all the tools and services you need to start, run, and grow your online sports betting business.


Complete the signup form


Select template and
configure your site
thumb-sportsbook copy


Promote your site and
start collecting money
Freedom to bet from anywhere

We are here with you every step of the way

Every hour of every day, we will have experts standing by to help you with every step of your journey. From setup, to how to maximize your player's experience -- our team is here to help.


Exciting bets
Live Chat